The society was granted its coat of arms by the Canadian Heraldic Authority in 2002.

The shield, white with a red cross and half maple leaves, refers to the traditional symbol of St. George and is the first time maple leaves have been used in this way.

The crest depicts St. George in armour and holding a red maple leaf, a white and a red rose, and a white trillium flower. The maple leaf represents Canada, the trillium represents Ontario, the roses refer to both England and Toronto (the white rose is also associated with York, the early nineteenth century name of Toronto). The red rose is also a reference to the Red Rose Ball, a major social event held annually by the society.

The lion is a reference to England and the bear is based on one of the supporters of the arms of the City of Toronto. They stand on a grassy mound on which there are golden maple leaves, seeds, and golden oak leaves and acorns. The leaves, seed and acorns further combine Canadian and English symbolism, with indications of renewal.

The motto - Always Loyal - was chosen by the society as a statement of enduring fidelity to its roots.

The society was also granted a flag and a badge.